Skip to content

Stiff sourdough starter: what it is and how to convert yours

Diagram converting a 100% hydration starter to a stiff 50% starter: 10 g starter plus 20 g flour plus 7.5 g water gives 25 g flour and 12.5 g water, which is 50% hydration

A stiff starter is a sourdough starter kept with much less water than flour. Instead of a runny, batter-like paste, it is a firm dough you can knead into a ball. Many bakers keep one by choice, and some recipes ask for one. You can turn the starter you already have into a stiff one in a single feed.

What “stiff” means

Hydration is the water divided by the flour. A typical starter fed equal weights of flour and water is 100% hydration. A stiff starter is usually around 50%: one part water to two parts flour. King Arthur Baking describes stiff starters as generally 50% to 65% hydration, against 100% to 125% for liquid ones.

Nothing else changes. It is the same culture, fed the same flour, just with less water.

Why bakers keep a stiff starter

  • It is easier to read. King Arthur’s baker finds it easier to tell when a stiff starter is ripe: it doubles, domes on top and is just starting to sink in the middle.
  • Some recipes call for one. A recipe may ask for a stiff starter or stiff levain by name.
  • It is less messy. A firm ball of starter is easy to handle and weigh.

You will often read that a stiff starter makes bread more sour or keeps better in the fridge. King Arthur removed both claims from its own article on stiff starters after review, so do not count on either. Try it and taste the difference in your own kitchen.

Convert in one feed

The trick is to remember that your starter already contains flour and water. 10 g of 100% starter is 5 g flour and 5 g water. To end up at exactly 50%, the total water must be half the total flour:

Flour Water
10 g of 100% starter 5 g 5 g
Fresh flour and water 20 g 7.5 g
Total 25 g 12.5 g

12.5 ÷ 25 = 50% hydration. So the one-step conversion is 10 g starter, 20 g flour, 7.5 g water (a 1 : 2 : 0.75 ratio). Mix it into a stiff dough, cover and leave it to rise.

The starter feeding calculator does this for any amount: enter your starter’s hydration and the ratio, and it shows the hydration you end up with.

Or convert gradually at 1 : 2 : 1

The Wild Yeast blog’s stiff starter method simply feeds a 100% starter at 1 : 2 : 1 (starter : flour : water) and keeps going. Because the seed brings extra water the first time, the hydration drifts down over a few feeds:

Feed Hydration after feeding 10 g starter with 20 g flour and 10 g water
1st 60%
2nd 52%
3rd 51%
4th 50%

By the third or fourth feed it is effectively at 50%. Either way works; the one-step method just gets there sooner. The new starter may rise more slowly for the first few feeds while it adjusts.

Feeding a stiff starter

Keep feeding flour and water at 2 : 1. How much flour depends on how warm it is and how long you want between feeds, the same as with a liquid starter. Wild Yeast feeds at 1 : 2 : 1 every 12 hours in winter, and at 1 : 3 : 1.5 or 1 : 4 : 2 in summer to slow it down. The feeding ratios guide explains how the ratio sets the timing.

Use it at its peak, a few hours after feeding, when it has risen well and domed.

Using a stiff starter in a recipe

A stiff starter brings less water into the dough than a 100% one, so if you swap it in gram for gram, the dough gets a little drier. To keep the same dough, add more water.

For a 900 g loaf at 75% hydration with 20% starter and 2% salt, the recipe calculator gives:

Starter type Starter Flour to add Water to add
100% hydration 102 g 458 g 331 g
50% hydration 102 g 441 g 348 g

That is about 17 g more water and 17 g less flour. Set the starter hydration in the calculator and it does the adjustment for you.

Converting back to 100%

Feed equal weights of flour and water at a high ratio, such as 1 : 5 : 5, and after a feed or two the stiff seed makes up so little of the jar that the starter is close to 100% again. The starter feeding calculator shows the exact figure.

Common questions

Is a stiff starter the same as a levain? No. A levain is a one-off build for a bake, which can be stiff or liquid. A stiff starter is the culture you keep. The levain calculator builds a stiff levain from a liquid starter if you only need one for a single recipe.

Is 60% or 65% still a stiff starter? Yes. Anything in the 50% to 65% range is usually called stiff. Pick one and keep feeding at that ratio.

Can I use a stiff starter for discard recipes? Yes, but it holds more flour and less water than 100% discard. The discard guide shows the split for a 50% starter.