Skip to content

Sourdough discard calculator

Add sourdough discard to pancakes, crackers or any recipe, with the flour and liquid reduced so the batter stays the same.

The recipe

g
g

Water or milk. 1 US cup of milk is about 240 g.

Your discard

g
%

Same as your starter, usually 100%.

Why you can't just stir discard in

Sourdough discard is the starter you remove before feeding. It is simply flour and water, usually in equal weights. Adding 100 g of it to a recipe on top of everything else adds about 50 g of flour and 50 g of water, which makes pancakes thicker, crackers wetter and quick breads denser than the recipe intended.

This calculator takes the discard's flour out of the recipe's flour and its water out of the recipe's main liquid. The batter ends up with the same total flour and liquid as the original, so it behaves the way the recipe expects, with the tang of sourdough added.

Worked example. A pancake recipe uses 250 g flour and 240 g milk. You have 100 g of discard at 100% hydration, which is 50 g flour and 50 g water.

Use 200 g flour, 190 g milk and the 100 g discard. Everything else in the recipe (eggs, sugar, baking powder, butter) stays the same.

The formula

Flour in discard = discard รท (1 + hydration)
Water in discard = discard โˆ’ flour in discard
Flour to use = recipe flour โˆ’ flour in discard
Liquid to use = recipe liquid โˆ’ water in discard

The most discard a recipe can take is limited by whichever runs out first, the flour or the liquid. The calculator shows that limit.

Things discard does and doesn't do

  • It doesn't reliably raise things. Unfed discard has little rising power. Keep the recipe's baking powder, baking soda or yeast.
  • It adds tang. Older discard is more sour. Discard kept for a while in the fridge gives a stronger flavour than discard from yesterday's feed.
  • It adds acidity. In recipes that use baking soda, the acid in discard reacts with the soda and releases gas, which can help a batter rise.
  • Milk is not exactly water. Milk is mostly water, so subtracting the discard's water from the milk works well for batters. For very precise baking, subtract it from any plain water in the recipe first.

Limits of this calculator

  • It adjusts flour and one main liquid. Recipes with several flours or liquids: take the reduction from the main one.
  • It works by weight. If your recipe uses cups, weigh the flour and liquid once and enter the grams.

Common questions

Can I just add discard to a recipe?

You can, but it adds flour and liquid the recipe never asked for, so batters thicken and doughs get wetter. Swapping it in keeps the recipe the same: 100 g of 100% discard means 50 g less flour and 50 g less liquid.

How much discard can a recipe take?

Until the recipe runs out of flour or liquid to swap. A recipe with 250 g flour and 240 g milk can take up to 480 g of 100% discard; the calculator shows the limit for your numbers.

Do I still need baking powder or baking soda?

Yes. Unfed discard has little rising power, so keep the recipe's leavening. In recipes with baking soda, the acid in discard can help the batter rise a little.

How long can I keep discard?

Many bakers keep it in a covered jar in the fridge and use it within a week or two. Older discard tastes more sour. Throw it away if you see pink or orange streaks or fuzzy mould. The discard guide covers storage.