How it works
There's no single "correct" bulk time. It depends on your starter, flour, dough temperature and how much starter you use. So this calculator starts from a time that already works for your recipe and adjusts it for two things that change from day to day.
- Temperature. Bakers' rules of thumb say fermentation time roughly doubles for every 8 °C (15 °F) the dough is colder, and halves when it's warmer (The Sourdough Journey). Others put it closer to doubling every 5 °C (9 °F) (Weekend Bakery). The result shows the range between the two.
- Starter amount. More starter is faster, less is slower. The Sourdough Journey's example is 20% starter finishing in about 5 hours and 10% in about 8. The calculator scales your time the same way.
Time now ≈ usual time × 2^((usual temp − temp now) ÷ 5 to 8 °C) × (usual starter ÷ starter now)^0.68
Worked example. Your recipe takes 5 hours at 75 °F (24 °C) with 20% starter. Today the dough is at 68 °F (20 °C).
That's 7 °F (about 3.9 °C) colder. On the 8 °C rule that's 5 × 2^(3.9 ÷ 8) ≈ 7 hours; on the 5 °C rule, 5 × 2^(3.9 ÷ 5) ≈ 8.6 hours. Plan for about 7 to 8½ hours and start checking the dough at 6.
Use it to plan, then watch the dough
These are rules of thumb, and the estimate is a planning range. End bulk fermentation when the dough is ready: risen by the amount your recipe asks for, domed, airy and jiggly. An aliquot jar takes the guesswork out of measuring the rise, and the schedule planner lays out the rest of your bake around it.
To bring a slow dough back on schedule, warm it up: the dough temperature calculator gives the water temperature to start warmer, and the cold kitchen guide has ways to keep it warm.
Limits
- It works between 50 °F and 95 °F (10 to 35 °C). Fridge bulk and very hot doughs behave differently.
- It assumes the same starter, flour and recipe. A sluggish starter, whole grain flour or a lot of salt or sugar all change the timing.
Common questions
How long should sourdough bulk fermentation take?
It depends mostly on dough temperature and how much starter you use. The Sourdough Journey gives an example of a dough with 20% starter finishing bulk in about 5 hours, and the same dough with 10% starter taking about 8. Use your own recipe's time as the starting point and this calculator adjusts it.
How much does temperature change bulk fermentation time?
A lot. Bakers' rules of thumb say the time roughly doubles for every 5 to 8 °C (9 to 15 °F) colder the dough is, and halves when it is that much warmer. A dough that takes 5 hours at 75 °F might take about 7 to 8.5 hours at 68 °F.
Should I go by time or by how much the dough has risen?
By the dough. Times are only a guide, because starters, flours and kitchens differ. Use the estimate to plan, then judge the end of bulk by rise and feel. An aliquot jar makes the rise easy to measure.
Does using less starter make sourdough more sour?
Less starter makes bulk fermentation slower, and longer, cooler fermentation is widely associated with a tangier flavour. Many bakers lower the starter in summer to keep bulk from finishing too fast.
Can I do bulk fermentation in the fridge?
This calculator is for room-temperature bulk between 10 and 35 °C (50 and 95 °F). Fridge temperatures slow fermentation so much that the rules of thumb no longer hold, so judge a cold bulk by the dough.